The Thin Man

What viewers say

Viewers adore the sparkling banter and obvious affection between the leading couple, a cocktail-loving detective and his witty wife, and say the film blends a whodunit with screwball comedy so neither side undercuts the other. The sharp dialogue, the lively supporting cast and the little dog are frequent favorites, and many say it still holds up decades later. Criticisms are that some of the acting is theatrical by modern standards, a few gags feel quaint, and the mystery is tangled and its resolution somewhat rushed. Heavy drinking is played for laughs throughout.

Best for: Viewers who want a witty classic-era mystery driven by a charming married couple more than by the puzzle.

Summary of public viewer reviews, updated November 2026.