About this series
Wicked Witches of Cauldron Hollow is a series by Sara Bourgeois. We list 9 books in this series so far, in reading order.
Start with Book 1: If the Hat Fits.
Tagged on most books in this series: Witches and Paranormal.
If you like Wicked Witches of Cauldron Hollow, try Mystic Caravan Mysteries by Amanda M. Lee, Spellbound Paranormal Cozy Mystery by Annabel Chase and A Reaper Witch Mystery by Elle Adams.
What readers say
Readers enjoy this witchy small-town series for its snarky talking cat familiar, a grounded heroine starting over after divorce who is slow to embrace her magic, a quirky town with a house that seems alive, and a slow-building romance with a sheriff who has more depth than usual. Many say later books get even better, with multiple mysteries and a slightly darker edge. Common criticisms are flat, mechanical prose, thin worldbuilding around the town and witch families, mysteries that are easy to solve and a premise that feels similar to the author's earlier series.
Best for: Readers who like light, clean witch cozies with a sassy feline sidekick.
Summary of public reader reviews, updated November 2026.
📖 Reading Order
Pin this series