Elsbeth

What viewers say

Viewers enjoy this lighthearted, Columbo-style mystery for Carrie Preston's quirky, warm performance as Elsbeth, the fun guest stars and a cheerful tone with little graphic violence. Many treat it as an easy, comforting weekly watch, and some feel the show found its footing in later seasons with sharper writing and higher stakes. Common complaints are that Elsbeth's eccentricity and some supporting performances can tip into over-the-top, a number of plots feel silly or implausible, cases can take a long time to set up and then wrap up quickly, and a few viewers dislike side plots such as her romance storyline.

Best for: Viewers who want a feel-good, character-driven mystery with a quirky lead rather than a tricky puzzle.

Summary of public viewer reviews, updated October 2026.