Jonathan Creek

What viewers say

Viewers remember this BBC impossible-crime series fondly for its clever locked-room puzzles, witty tone and the odd-couple dynamic between the gadget-loving magic consultant and his sidekick, with praise for the supporting cast. It's frothy, offbeat fun that critics say looks a little creaky now. The most common criticism is that later series lose some magic: the leads were unconvincing as a couple, the show is weaker without the original sidekick, and the 2014 revival leaned on nostalgia. Some fans also disliked how the main character changes.

Best for: Viewers who love impossible-crime puzzles with a quirky, comic edge and an affection for 90s British TV.

Summary of public viewer reviews, updated November 2026.