Murdoch Mysteries

What viewers say

Viewers enjoy this Edwardian-era Toronto detective series for its clever, science-minded cases, the period sets, the ensemble cast and cameos by real historical figures, and its comparatively gentle tone, which many say is a refreshing change from grittier procedurals. Long-time fans often call it a favorite. The recurring criticisms are that the early episodes had an uneven tone, that later seasons recycle plots and lean on cases tied to the detective's own circle, and that some viewers dislike the modern sensibility, acting or historical accuracy. Death is a constant theme with some blood, though violence is rarely graphic.

Best for: Viewers who like cozy-leaning period mysteries with inventions and history, and who may prefer the earlier seasons.

Summary of public viewer reviews, updated November 2026.